Israel and Menucha Hulati

Menucha was murdered, Israel's Home was destroyed

Menucha and Israel Hulati

Menucha and Israel Hulati lived in separate homes in Kibbutz Kissufim for years. On October 7th, red alert sirens forced them into their safe rooms. By midday, contact with Menucha was lost. The next morning, Israel left his ruined home, went to Menucha's and found her lifeless, burnt body

Menucha and Israel Hulati. Photo: Einat Hulati

Menucha was murdered, Israel's Home was destroyed

Menucha and Israel Hulati

Minute by Minute Circle
06:30
08:08
~13:20
14:55
15:16
~16:30
~21:00
+09:15
+~10:30
+~11:00

The sequence of events

Minute by Minute

Click on the points on the timeline for a real-time tour. Clicking on the icons will display the event documentation.

06:30

Red Alerts in Kibbutz Kissufim

08:08

Israel to Menucha: “Do not leave the house.”

~13:20

Contact with Menucha is Lost

14:55

Menucha Tries Writing to Israel

15:16

Menucha is Murdered

~16:30

Terrorists Set Kibbutz House on Fire

~21:00

Kibbutz Survivor Informs Family of Menucha's Murder

+09:15

Israel's House Destroyed by Tank Shell

+~10:30

Israel Leaves his Safe Room and Discovers Menucha has Been Murdered

+~11:00

Evacuation From the Kibbutz

Exit Media
Exit Media

Menucha and Israel Hulati, both 76, have lived in Kibbutz Kissufim for five decades. In recent years, they reside in separate homes. As red alert sirens blare across the kibbutz, they find refuge in their safe rooms. About half an hour later, their daughter Einat, who lives in Kfar Azar, messages her mother, Menucha, and they agree to speak later

Exit Media
Menucha Hulati Near her Kibbutz Home
Menucha Hulati Near her Kibbutz Home
Exit Media
Menucha (blue) and Israel's (yellow) House's Location in Kibbutz Kissufim
Menucha (blue) and Israel's (yellow) House's Location in Kibbutz Kissufim Map of Google Earth
Exit Media
Messaging Between Menucha and her Daughter Einat
Einat
Good morning 😘
06:55 07/10/2023
Menucha
I'll call you later
07:03 07/10/2023
Einat
Yes, we'll talk later ♥️
07:04 07/10/2023
Exit Media

Israel quickly realizes that terrorists have infiltrated the surrounding kibbutz communities and sends Menucha a message: 'Do not leave the house.' Later, he urges her to lock herself inside her safe room

Exit Media
Israel's Conversation With Menucha
Israel
Don't leave the house!
08:08 07/10/2023
Israel
There's a terrorist infiltrations into many Kibbutz's in the region.
08:24 07/10/2023
Israel
Stay inside the safe room and don't go outside. Make sure to lock the front house door.
08:59 07/10/2023
Menucha
09:01 07/10/2023
Israel
Terrorists are inside the Kibbutz.
10:51 07/10/2023
Israel
Lock yourself inside the safe room.
11:00 07/10/2023
Israel
Get into the safe room and lock yourself there!
11:21 07/10/2023
Exit Media

The electricity and cellular networks in the kibbutz are cut, leaving family members unable to reach Menucha

Exit Media
Messaging Between Einat and Menucha
Menucha
13:14 07/10/2023
Einat
A fine sense of humor 😂😘
13:42 07/10/2023
Einat
Contact check.
14:17 07/10/2023
Einat
Please reply that you're alright.
14:17 07/10/2023
Einat
I guess there's no cellular connection, Please reply as soon as you receive this.
14:39 07/10/2023
Exit Media

Menucha sends a message to Israel, but he never receives it due to disruptions in the communication network

Exit Media
Menucha's Message to Israel During Power Outage
Menucha
Israel, there's is no electricity.
14:55 07/10/2023
Exit Media

The last message on Menucha's phone sent at 15:16, is a random sequence of letters. It is believed that shortly after this message, Menucha was murdered by terrorists inside her safe room. About an hour later, her phone captures a screenshot showing a search for the contact "Eti Zak," Menucha's neighbour, who is also murdered that same Saturday

Exit Media
Menucha's Last Message to Israel
Menucha
YBFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
15:16 07/10/2023
Exit Media

Terrorists set the kibbutz's row of houses, including Menucha's, ablaze

Exit Media
Houses Set Ablaze Next to Menucha’s Home
Houses Set Ablaze Next to Menucha’s Home Photo: Kathryn Grosswirth
Exit Media

By evening, security forces evacuate residents from the kibbutz. Einat and her husband, Moshe Apron, stay informed of the situation. Moshe decides to head to Orim Junction, hoping Menucha might make her way there. However, while en route, he realises the evacuees are being moved to Beit Kama Junction, so he drives there instead. Upon arrival, he meets Eve Mimis, Menucha's neighbour, and her nursing caregiver. Menucha's caregiver informs Moshe that Menucha has been murdered, though the family cannot confirm this at the time.

Exit Media

After spending over a day locked in the safe room of his home, Israel opens the door and speaks with four combatants from the IDF's Egoz unit who are operating in the kibbutz. He asks them if he can leave the area, but they reply that he cannot. He then turns back, locks the door, and suddenly hears shouts from outside: "Terrorist in the house." Moments later, a battle erupts between the troops and terrorists hiding in a neighbouring apartment complex. Following the exchange of fire, which lasts about forty minutes, Israel hears the troops outside receive the order: "Take the house down." An hour later, once the battle ceases, a tank fires a shell at the house, destroying it

Exit Media
Israel Tells of his Experience Leaving his Safe Room After Spending More Than 30 Hours locked Inside
00:00
00:00
From “Nowhere Else”, Kan Bet
Exit Media
Israel’s Home Following the Battles
Israel’s Home Following the Battles
Exit Media
The Aftermath of the Tank Shelling on the House
The Aftermath of the Tank Shelling on the House
Exit Media

At the end of the battle, Israel emerges from his safe room. He sees that his house is destroyed and notices soldiers outside. He walks with them through the kibbutz and asks them to check Menucha's house. One of the soldiers enters the house and informs Israel, "There’s nothing in there." Unsatisfied, Israel decides to enter the house himself. He notices gunshot marks on the safe room door, continues further, and then discovers Menucha’s burnt body

Exit Media
Bullet Holes Found in Israel's Safe Room Door
Bullet Holes Found in Israel's Safe Room Door Photo: Einat Hulati
Exit Media
Israel Shares the Moment He Discovered Menucha’s Burnt Body
00:00
00:00
From “Nowhere Else”, Kan Bet
Exit Media

Security forces evacuate Israel to the city of Ofakim. Later that day, he arrives at his daughter Einat's house in Kfar Azar

The Day After

10/18/23

Menucha Laid to Rest

10/18/23

Menucha's Cell Phone Retrieved

Beginning of September 2024

Menucha’s Grave Moved to Kibbutz Kissufim
Exit Media

Menucha's funeral held at Kibbutz Giv'at Brenner

Exit Media

An officer from the paratrooper brigade locates Menucha's cell phone in a moshav near Ofakim. He contacts the family and hands them the device. This is how Menucha’s family learns more about what happened to her on October 7th, including the last messages she had attempted to send

Exit Media

Menucha's family moves her grave to Kibbutz Kissufim. About a month later, they held a ceremony to unveil her grave's tombstone

Exit Media
President Isaac Herzog Joins Israel at Menucha’s Tombstone Unveiling President Isaac Herzog Joins Israel at Menucha’s Tombstone Unveiling Photo: Einat Hulati
Exit Image
Exit Media